Reviewing

All final submissions are reviewed for content, balance, playability and relevance. This assessment is relayed back to the author along with any recommendations for change before posting for download.

Before Downloading the submission is given a rating.

Rating

New ratings are

a)     Over powerful

In interesting idea but one which could easily overcome or change a game by its adoption.

b)     Average

An interesting idea or variation on a theme, but not one that will fit into every game without further modification.

c)     Good-

An interesting, well balanced idea or variation, which should fit into any game world without further modification.

d)     Very Good

A very unusual or novel idea, which will benefit any game world they are introduced into.

e)     Relic

A professional submission, complete and individual, which would benefit any game world, show this to your friends.

Old Ratings

Previous Ratings were based on, some submissions are rated in this manner.

  1. Comic/Weird -- Material with a novel idea but which is clearly comical, or too weird to play in most of the standard d20 rules/settings.
  2. Powerful/Unbalanced -- An interesting idea or content that should not be used without modification.
  3. Classic -- Material that is reasonably balance and ok to use with standard d20 rules/setting without too much modifications.
  4. Relic -- Material that is original, balanced, well written and can be slotted into most campaign worlds without modification.


Back

BACK TO COMMUNITY: 3E